Xero Accounting Gold Champion Partner

Budget or Cash Flow Forecast – which is best?

budget-or-cash-flow-forecast

Understanding the fundamental differences between a business budget and a cash flow forecast is crucial for effective financial management. While both are vital planning tools, a budget primarily focuses on profitability based on incurred income and expenses (accrual accounting), whereas a cash flow forecast tracks the actual movement of cash in and out of the business, highlighting liquidity over time.

Navigating the financial landscape requires foresight and strategic planning. For business owners, utilising tools like a budget and a cash flow forecast is essential for making informed decisions and ensuring long-term sustainability. Despite their importance, these tools are often underutilised, potentially due to a lack of clarity on their specific roles and benefits.

Successfully managing your business’s finances involves understanding where you stand today and anticipating future financial events. This anticipation is made possible through the diligent creation and regular review of both your budget and your cash flow forecast.

Understanding the distinct purpose and application of each tool is the first step toward leveraging their full power.

What is a Business Budget?

A business budget is a detailed financial plan that projects your company’s expected income and expenses over a specific period, typically a year, broken down by month or quarter. It is compiled using financial data, most commonly derived from your Profit & Loss (P&L) statement.

Budgets primarily operate on accrual accounting principles. This means income is recognised when it is earned (regardless of when cash is received), and expenses are recorded when they are incurred (regardless of when they are paid). The output of a budget is a projected monthly profit or loss figure, illustrating the business’s planned profitability.

This accrual-based perspective is the standard method for financial reporting required by external stakeholders like banks, investors, and tax authorities. While it provides a clear picture of profitability over time, it doesn’t necessarily reflect the actual cash available in the business’s bank account at any given moment.

How Do You Create a Business Budget?

Compiling an accurate budget requires a thorough understanding of your business’s historical financial performance and reasonable projections for the future.

  1. Gather Historical Data: The most reliable starting point is your historical financial records, specifically past P&L statements. Analyse previous years’ income and expense figures to identify trends and patterns.
  2. Project Future Income: Estimate future revenue based on sales forecasts, market trends, and planned business activities. Be realistic in your projections.
  3. Estimate Future Expenses: Project both fixed expenses (rent, salaries) and variable expenses (cost of goods sold, marketing). Consider anticipated changes like price increases or new hires.
  4. Categorise Consistently: Ensure your budget uses the same account categories as your accounting system. This consistency is critical for easily comparing your actual results against your budgeted figures each month.
  5. Determine Your Break-Even Point: Understanding the revenue level required to cover all your costs is a crucial part of budgeting. It helps validate whether your planned income is sufficient or if expense adjustments are needed.

A budget serves as a target and a benchmark, guiding operational decisions and providing a standard against which performance can be measured.

What is a Cash Flow Forecast?

A cash flow forecast is a projection of the actual cash coming into and leaving your business over a specific period. Unlike a budget that focuses on profitability, a cash flow forecast focuses purely on liquidity – whether you will have sufficient cash on hand to meet your obligations as they become due.

A forecast tracks cash inflows (money received from sales, loans, investments) and cash outflows (money paid for expenses, supplier invoices, loan repayments, taxes). It does not show whether your business is profitable according to accrual principles, but it will clearly indicate if you anticipate cash surpluses or deficits at specific points in time.

Cash flow forecasts are inherently proactive tools. Ideally, they should be reviewed and updated regularly, often monthly or even weekly, to anticipate potential cash shortages before they occur. By forecasting cash movements, businesses can identify periods of tightness and plan strategies to manage them, such as delaying payments, accelerating collections, or arranging short-term financing.

If a transaction affects your bank balance, it needs to be included in your cash flow forecast.

How Do You Implement a Cash Flow Forecast?

Implementing a cash flow forecast involves tracking the timing of cash movements.

  1. Start with Your Opening Cash Balance: The forecast begins with the actual cash amount currently available in your bank account(s).
  2. Project Cash Inflows: Estimate when cash is expected to be received from customers (factoring in payment terms and typical collection delays), grants, loans, or other sources.
  3. Project Cash Outflows: Estimate when cash will be paid out for expenses (salaries, rent, utilities), supplier invoices, loan payments, taxes, and other disbursements.
  4. Calculate Net Cash Flow: Subtract projected outflows from projected inflows for each period (week or month) to determine the net cash change.
  5. Determine Ending Cash Balance: Add the net cash flow to the opening balance for the period to get the ending balance, which then becomes the opening balance for the next period.
  6. Update Regularly: A cash flow forecast is a dynamic document. It must be updated frequently based on actual cash movements and changes in expected payment/receipt timing. For instance, a delayed customer payment requires updating the expected receipt date in the forecast. Using accounting software that integrates with banking can simplify this process significantly compared to manual tracking.

Budget vs. Cash Flow Forecast: Which Tool Should Your Business Use?

Both a budget and a cash flow forecast are indispensable tools for sound financial management. They serve distinct but complementary purposes:

  • Your Budget: Shows your planned profitability over time, based on accrual accounting. It helps answer questions about pricing, cost control, and overall business model viability.
  • Your Cash Flow Forecast: Shows your projected liquidity (cash position) over time, based on cash accounting. It helps answer questions about your ability to pay bills, fund operations, and manage working capital day-to-day.

You shouldn’t choose one over the other; you need both. The insights from your budget (e.g., anticipated profitability) can inform your cash flow forecast (e.g., potential timing of tax payments or owner draws), and changes in your cash flow forecast (e.g., anticipating a cash crunch) might prompt adjustments to your budget (e.g., finding ways to cut expenses).

Together, the budget and cash flow forecast provide a comprehensive view of your business’s financial health, allowing you to anticipate challenges, seize opportunities, and make proactive, informed decisions. Effectively utilising both tools empowers business owners to navigate financial complexities with greater confidence.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Scroll to Top